Reverend James Hugh McNeilly

Chaplain, 49thTennessee Infantry Regiment C. S. A. 

~by 1st Regt. Cmdr. Billy Jackson / Sam Watkins Camp 29 Columbia, TN

J. H. McNeilly was the commissioned Chaplain of the 49th Tennessee Infantry Regiment.      He is one of many men of this regiment who distinguished themselves on the field of battle and, in the post war South.   When folks think about Military Chaplains, they tend to get a picture in their mind of the characters portrayed on such television series as M.A.S.H.  An impression of a person far behind the lines who rarely sees the front line and never comes under fire.   In the War for Southern Independence, the Chaplain played a vital role, right on the front line administering to the spiritual needs of the men and in some cases, caring for the wounded.

 

       James was born on Jones Creek in Dickson County, Tennessee in June,1838.  He was  the son of Robert and Margaret McNeilly, hard working Scots who were first generation Tennesseans.

       James entered Jackson College, from which he graduated with the class of 1856. He was afterwards employed for quite awhile as a surveyor in Dickson and surrounding countries, and in 1860 was licensed as a Presbyterian preacher, having graduated form the Seminary at Danville, Kentucky.

      James Hugh McNeilly was a front line Chaplain in all aspects.  He saw some of the fiercest combat that a man could experience; yet amidst all of the hardships and death, he kept his faith.  His writings after the war give some of the clearest, most concise insights into what these battles and their aftermath were like.   From Vicksburg to Nashville, 'Spider Wagin' as he was called by the troops (owing to the fact he carried all the cooking utensils for the regiment and troops called skillets spiders due to the legs on the vessels) followed his boys, ministering to their spiritual needs and nursing their wounds.  

      He was their Minister, their best friend, the subject of pranks and at times, the object of their affection.   Along the way, he gathered the material that in his later years would form the basis for some of the best writings ever submitted to Confederate Veteran.  From humorous to straightforward accounts of the battlefield, his writings paint a picture in your mind that allows you to get an idea of what it was like to ~see the elephant~

     I would like to share with you some of the Rev. McNeilly's literary efforts and, encourage you to take the time to read those old volumes of the Veteran to get the story straight from the men who were there.

 

EARLY EXPERIENCES OF WAR 

   J. H. McNeilly enlisted at Vicksburg with Company D, 49th Tennessee, and a company that was formed in his home county of Dickson in Northern Middle Tennessee.    At age 25, he had just finished his studies at the Danville Seminary when the war broke.   He wanted to serve and since his brother was captured when Ft. Donelson fell and, since the Confederate Government ordered Chaplains be assigned to all regiments, he headed south to Mississippi, where he met with the regiment upon its exchange at Vicksburg.  

   He arrived several days in advance of the regiment and his first encounter with a Confederate soldier left him with only the clothes on his back when, while checking into a Vicksburg hotel, his carpet bag was stolen by a roving soldier.  McNeilly later stated that the loss of his clothes did not bother him as much as the loss of his Bible and his sermons, which he had taken many hours to write.  He considered the Rebel soldier to be a profane sort of individual indeed after this encounter but managed to settle in with the regiment at Clinton, Mississippi in September.

    His first days were spent catching up with his brother, who had just been exchanged.   His brother, already a soldier, experienced in the fray and, the way of the vile Yankee, related the following story to James during those first days in camp near Vicksburg.

 

ON CAMP DOUGLAS

My brother told me of one experience of his.     It was against the rule for the prisoners to talk with citizens, especially to argue.    One day, a citizen who was visiting the prison accosted my brother as he stood inside a lattice screen and asked him some questions.

'Did you all have plenty to eat down South?'

'Yes'

'Did you have comfortable clothes?'

'Yes'

'Well, did you have houses to live in?'

'O, Yes'

'Then what in the world are you fighting for?'

     The reply was:  'There is something more to live for than victuals and clothes.  We are fighting for the same thing our fathers fought for in the Revolution.'

     A sentry had been listening to the talk until this point; but the moment he heard a word to imitate that we were contending for Liberty, he raised his gun and fired, shattering the lattice work above my brothers head.

 

AT THE  SIEGE OF  PORT  HUDSON

      James first real experience in combat came a t a place called Port Hudson, Louisiana.  The regiment had been sent back and forth all across the state of Mississippi and as far south as Fort Morgan at Mobile Bay.  By March 1863, the 49th had been moved to Port Hudson.  Just days later, the siege of the river fortress began, giving James his first glimpse of the element of War and, its effect on the soldier.   It was at Port Hudson that he began to jot down his experiences and observations, a couple of which I share with you now.

 

1      The 30th Louisiana were the Acadians (or Cajuns) and spoke only French.  The language was a wonder to our Tennessee country boys and, they always stopped to listen to what they called the jabbering.  There were several washerwomen with the 30th, and they talked incessantly with characteristic French vivacity.  One of our boys expressed it. After listening for a while to their chatter, he called to a comrade; Run here and listen to these women.  One of them can give one flutter of her tongue and say more than you can say in a week.

2       As we stood in line during the bombardment the frogs in a puddle kept up a constant chattering, when this boy said to me; These frogs have camped by the side of the 30th Louisiana till they have learned to talk French.

3      One of the saddest incidents of the bombardment was a tragedy indeed, begun with some comic features.   There were a good many negroes in camp, Cooks and Teamsters.  They were generally much frightened by the bursting shells and ran in various directions, hunting places of safety.   As one of them rushed by, someone called to him; Tom,  its time for you to be praying!    He accepted this suggestion and flopped down on his knees and began the only prayer he knew'; 'Now I lay me down to sleep'  

        Just then, his eye caught sight of one of the big shells from the mortar boats soaring up into the heavens with its burning fuse until it seemed just over his head; He didn't wait to finish.     With 'O, Lord, I done forget de res' he started again on the run and, in his blind terror he struck his forehead against a projecting pole of a cabin, his neck was broken and he fell dead.   It was remarkable, the change the bombardment made in many of the negroes.   Before, they were a careless, happy-go-lucky set, many of them quite profane.   Afterwards, they indulged largely in camp meeting songs, and one could not twist an oath out of them with a corkscrew.
     
From Port Hudson, the 49th Tennessee moved northward to Vicksburg as part of Joe
Johnston's Army of Relief.  When Vicksburg fell, the regiment had only made it as far as the Big Black River, just west of Jackson, Mississippi.  They were then sent into Georgia, arriving just after the Battle of Missionary Ridge had been decided.  They spent a few days at Dalton, Georgia where the Army of Tennessee had went into winter camp, then they went back into Mississippi to attempt to check the advance of Sherman.  When the Army of Tennessee came out of winter camp, the regiment was once again transported to Georgia, this time to take part in the Atlanta Campaign.

 

THE  BRAVE  CHAPLAIN

      McNeilly wrote accounts of almost every battle his boys found themselves in. From Atlanta, he told of the bloody fight at Lickskillet Road where every officer of his regiment was killed or wounded in the first 15 minutes, of how he helped his wounded commander off the field and, of how after finding his Adjutant dead on the field, he buried him in an Atlanta rose garden at midnight, complete with General Bate as mourner.  He was cited for his gallantry in the actions of Ezra Church / Lickskillet Road by General W. A.. Quarles, his brigade commander, who stated,

     'I cannot refrain from mentioning the conduct of the Rev, J. H.. McNeilly, chaplain of the 49th Tennessee.  At all times a consistent and faithful follower of the Master, on this occasion he exhibited the qualities of the Christian Soldier. Following the blood-stained path of his regiment, he was everywhere to be seen ministering to the physical and spiritual needs of the wounded and dying.

 

TENNESSEE CAMPAIGN

 

Some of the Rev. McNeilly's most profound and revealing work comes from his accounts surrounding the Battles of Franklin and Nashville. Losing his own brother to a Union bullet near the Gin House, McNeilly spent the entire night of the battle of Franklin searching out the wounded, taking them to safety and medical care, this after he had located and buried his brother.  McNeilly stayed with his boys, aiding them in any way he could until the army moved out to Nashville.   He later stated that during the battle of Franklin, the 49th Tennessee sustained a casualty rate of 85%, going into battle with some 108 men and losing 92.

     McNeilly stated later: 'Most of the men seemed to realize that our charge on the enemy's works would be attended with heavy slaughter, and several of them came to me bringing watches, jewelry, letters and photographs, asking me to take charge of them and send them to their family if they were killed.   I had to decline, as I was going with them and would be exposed to the same danger.  It was vividly recalled by me the next morning, for I believe that every one who had made this request of me was killed.'

      He had moved his wounded to an outbuilding at Carnton Plantation and then began searching for bandages, food and any items he could find in the town to ease the suffering of his comrades.  His first attempts at foraging were met with disbelief by some of the ladies of Franklin, who seeing this disheveled man at their door, thought him to be just a common soldier looking for food.  He finally produced his Chaplains Commission and convinced the ladies his intentions were pure.  His state of dress, even as a Chaplain, was as bad or worse as any other Confederate on the field that day.

     He described his uniform as such;  'Beginning at the top, I wore a hat of brown jeans quilted, which on occasion could hold a quart of rain water.  I had on a checked shirt that would not button at the throat.   My jacket of cotton goods had a big round hole six inches wide made by a shell exploding over it as it lay on the ground.  My trousers hung from my knees to my ankles in ribbons and my almost footless socks were encased by a pair of shoes which the body and sole were held together by strings.  I certainly presented a disreputable appearance for a Chaplain.' 

 

POST WAR EXPERIENCES

        Dr. McNeilly returned to Nashville in November 1867, as pastor of the Woodland Street Presbyterian Church. While there he organized the Moore Memorial Church on Broadway, which he afterwards served for over eleven years, from 1879 to 1890. He then organized Glen Leven Church, which he served for twenty years.    He rendered pastoral service for the First Presbyterian Church at various times when it was without a pastor, so that nearly his entire post war ministerial life was spent in Nashville.  In 1911, these four Churches, realizing that Dr. McNeilly was beyond seventy years of age and nearly blind, determined to relieve him of pastoral responsibilities and care for him for the rest of his life, so they made him pastor emeritus of the four Churches, and provided for his support.

 

IN  LATER  YEARS

    Before his death on September 28, 1922, McNeilly had submitted over 15 articles to the Veteran along with numerous book reviews.  He delivered eulogies for his comrades and other men and women of prominence in the Confederate community as they passed on, making sure he submitted each and every one to the Confederate Veteran.  He served as Chaplain for the Tennessee UCV for several terms, which gave him the opportunity to remain close to his surviving comrades of the 49th.

      He gave the invocation at the dedication ceremony of the Battle of Nashville Monument and many more important events for the UCV.   He has one book to his credit that I know of titled, RELIGION AND SLAVERY , he wrote in 1912.

       The death of the Reverend James Hugh McNeilly saddened the editors of the Confederate Veteran so that his image graced the cover of the November 1922 edition and his memorial notice took two pages to print.


As year by year we pay our tribute of respect and love to those whose ashes we guard, we owe it to them, to ourselves, and to our posterity to vindicate their motives from aspersion, and to proclaim their achievements to the world. They fought for a cause which they believed to be right, and which we still believe to be right, for questions of right and wrong before God are not settled by success or defeat of arms.

~Rev. James Hugh McNeilly

49 TN Inf. Co. D,  Quarles Brigade

C.S.A

 

A BLESSING FOR GEN. FORREST.

 

Rev. J. H. McNeilly, a Confederate chaplain:

 

The impression prevalent about our great cavalry general does not credit him with much religious sentiment, yet there were many things in his career which showed a deep reverence for genuine religion. One of his most trusted officers was Col. D. C. Kelley, a Methodist preacher, who maintained his Christian character consistently all through the war, and who was one of the wariest and most dashing of his subordinate commanders. For Col. Kelley he had the profoundest respect, recognizing his sincere piety as well as his splendid courage.

 

A little incident told me directly after the war will illustrate the tender side of Gen. Forrest's nature. It was told to me by members of my grandfather's family. My mother's father lived six miles south of the little village of Charlotte, in Dickson County, Tenn., on a farm which was granted to his father for services as captain in the Revolutionary war. He was nearly ninety years old at the beginning of the civil war. Though he had loved the Union devotedly, he deeply regretted that he could not fight for the South. He believed in her cause with all his heart. He had his old rifle cleaned and placed where he could lay his hands on it, should occasion arise for him to use it against an invading foe.

 

On one of his expeditions into Tennessee I think it was on the way to Fort Donelson in 1863Gen. Forrest spent a night at my grandfather's, and, by his considerate attention, won the old man's heart. The next morning, when the General and his personal attendants were ready to start, the old gentleman, though nearly blind, must needs accompany him part of the way. So, taking his staff in his hand and one of his grandchildren to lead him, he walked along by the General's horse until they came to the main road at the edge of the farm. When the General stopped to bid his host good by the escort rode on. The old man asked him to get off his horse, which he did. He then asked him to kneel down.  Then, laying his hands on the General's head and lifting his sightless eyes to heaven, the old patriarch solemnly invoked the blessing of God on Gen. Forrest, on his men, and on the cause for which he was fighting. The General's face was bathed in tears as he remounted his horse.

 

In a year my grandfather was laid in his grave. Gen. Forrest lived to win many victories during the war, and afterwards he became a humble Christian. It may be that prayer was one of the influences that kept him safe through many dangers and finally led him to that Saviour in whom the old man trusted.

 

 

p.447               Confederate Veteran October 1899.

 

 

Last Update January 30, 2007
Copyright © 1994-  - All rights reserved
Site hosted by
D~N~J Web Design

 

If you arrived at this page while surfing the web
click here to view all pages:
Camp 260

Hit Counter